My Ex Says He Is Happier Without Me

Another thing is that he had another kid by his ex which used to be my friend. The odd thing. A break up is hard to bear, but moving on is worse, especially if you're still in love with your ex. I did my part and let him know about my feelings to him. I don't like it when he does it, but the last time we were together, I was in his arms while we kissed and yes, it's the best thing that I felt in my life. We are always friendly in my dreams and he's always trying to tell me something and is very kind or holding my hand. Whether he really loved you or not is NOT. Like I was the only one trying. Also, he setup payments to be withdrawn from my individually owned checking account. Wondering “will my boyfriend break up with me”? Find out now. Posted on May 15, 1998 by Becky Sweat 3 comments Estimated reading time: 9 minutes. com he will solve all your relationship problems and issue you. He was more than happy to let me go since he is not a football fanatic. There are lots of sweet things to say to your ex boyfriend or girlfriend without being romantic. A week ago we've been to a concert and he wrote me how much he enjoyed to spend the evening with me and that it was very important to him. he constantly post about how life is beautiful and good and how every thing is getting better on instagram. Almost all women check on an ex’s profile to see if he’s getting on with his life without her, or if he’s being sad and lonely. If your ex is bothering you, you have the ability to think to yourself "no, I do not have to deal with you bringing pain into my life by contacting me" and you can not respond. But it IS a lot more positive a sign than you might initially realize. For example, she says he never shares his feelings and withdraws; she says he gives perfunctory answers to her questions and does not confide in her, which makes her feel neglected. Focus on having fun and reminding your ex of how good they feel when they're around you. He was controlling and mistreated me in countless ways, every day. I finally spoke up and yelled. but it is really easier say then done. I regret sitting at home blaming myself when he’s out “doing him”, because I know exactly what he’s doing. D G D Bm I will enter His gates with thanksgiving in my heart D G A7 I will enter His courts with praise D G F#m Bm I will say this is the day that the Lord has made Em A D I will rejoice for He has made me glad Ch: D G He has made me glad D Bm He has made me glad Em A D G D I will rejoice for He has made me glad D7 G He has made me glad F#m Bm. Reconciliation with a Hardened Wife. Months and. I intend to find my ex boyfriend and he gets to know. He smiled, turned off the light and went to another room. My ex seems to be doing fine without me? I talked to my ex last week and when i called he was asleep apparantly he was up late the night before. I always told myself to cherish. Tell Me About It: I hate that my girlfriend is friends with her ex-lovers It’s getting me down and I am thinking about it a lot. A narcissist by definition, needs you more than you need them. My ex-husband never apologized for cheating on me; My ex-husband never apologized for cheating on me. Was married young (20) and after 30 years (with ups and downs of course), my hubby told me he no long had any feelings for me. He put me down. My ex- 7 years ago is still contolling my emotions. Thank you so much! When I was longing for love in my life and When I cried to lord, before I ask for someone, lord himself sent a guy to me. Anyways one morning I woke up had a bath and my ex stabbed me. I stopped talking to my ex because it felt disingenuous, but I hope to God he's happy these days. Find out what to do when your ex boyfriend is still talking to you after the end of your relationship, but doesn't want you back just yet. I never felt better in my life than I did that day. After that, we texted, called…. So he dropped me and my daughter home and told me we can't get on,and he need space, he would see my daughter from now on and that's it. This is where my questions start. But he's doing just fine. They have only been married 6 months and already taking separate vacations! I know he wasn't alone on his vacation! I tried to warn her but she thinks she is different, something special, better than all the rest and can heal him. Mariella Frostrup says a harmoniously blended. He couldn't look at me but did when he hand me my keys, I was acting happy. Now my ex-hubby wants me n kids back, saying the mistress is nothing n can be send packing anytime if I say yes to him. Question: "How can I know when God is telling me to do something?" Answer: Pray, especially when you’re unsure of God’s will for your life. It has taken me years, decades in fact, to learn that when my ex-husband said he really didn't want children, he meant it (and it shows in his relationship with our kids). My post “7 Ways a Wife Injures a Husband…Without Even Knowing It” has been a popular (and unpopular) post. My ex called me, I was so surprised, I answered the call and all he said was that he was so sorry for everything that happened, that he wanted me to return to him, that he loves me so much. None of my friends get it or understand, and I know the best thing for me is to probably go to therapy, but since my narcissist ex has degraded me to my very core already, I want to try my hardest to find my strength from within and get over this myself without giving my ex narc the even bigger ego boost of knowing he messed me up so badly that. How To Take The Last Step of Getting Over Your Ex. I am pregnant with his child and we raised my other child together since he as 3 weeks old. At least right now. And no, I didn't jump into the arms of the next hottie that winked in my direction just to have a warm body next to me in my very empty bed. He is living with someone else now and he is de laying the divorce. My x would say Iam Perfect… which now after many long years of reflection without him, that he never thought he was perfect. I know the feeling. Help you guys! My ex wants to get back together but says he "needs space". From nowhere he called me and said that he is in love with for 18long years. Which had me confused because if he wants to be a father to my children but then says he dooesn't love me anymore, why would he want to be be there for me n them and why is it that his ex seems to be an influence on his decision. What to do when your husband or wife is in love with someone else and having an affair. I just don’t know what else to do to make him happy. My husband of over 40 years is in the final months of his life. I pushed my family away cuz he acts crazy with them. After that, we texted, called…. He said himself, “I could get you back with a snap of my fingers”. Then, last week, one of my friends told me that my cheating ex-boyfriend is having a baby with his new girlfriend and she’s already six months pregnant (it was unplanned, apparently). Martin McGuinness was protected by MI5 for years while an IRA commander, ex-agent says When Willie Carlin's cover was blown in March 1985, Margaret Thatcher sent her ministerial jet to Aldergrove. We lived together and were moving into a new house. He smiled and said, “I do. Reason #3 Your ex says he doesn't love you anymore. Here are a few ways to tell if he's insecure: If he…. Its been about a month now, and he finally got back to me saying he totally forgot about it, and to sell it to someone else. My ex keeps threatening me, saying that I need to write him a receipt for all the back child support he owes me or he is going to take me back to court because I am living with my boyfriend. And the worst part about it was that I had no real reason to distrust my current partner. He's at home under Hospice support - he has tumors in his brain, lungs, trachea, and adrenal glands. Guys, we injure our wives. It was a complete victory. I am a twenty-something gay man. "Everyone knows how I feel about Mr. I am also married and have children. ” It made me realize that there are 9 distinct stages of marital disharmony. Last week, I lost a dear friend of mine to illness. He will ignore me when I ask him a question but then be very playful at others times. I am eternally grateful for your trust, and appreciate you allowing me to have this time off work. I pushed my family away cuz he acts crazy with them. In fact, when you keep tabs on what your ex is up to, where he or she is and/or who he or she’s with, you’re actually just keeping him or her in your life. He tells me to stop nagging him and that he drinks because i nag and i just say i am on my nerves constantly when he goes out as he always will go out drinking. Since you don't indicate whether your "ex- " is an ex-husband or simply an ex-boyfriend who has never been legally determined (by a court) to be the father, it isn't obvious that he has any rights to do or say anything. "He seems so much happier without me. So my world was falling apart. She went through all the appropriate treatment and within a year, had a recurrence. I just want to know this 'cause I just keep thinking of how my ex seems to be so fine without me in his life, how he has kept NC so easily, how he could end off things with me like he did and keep me here with no closure and so much pain but yet when he loves me as much as he said he did. I have just left a very mentally draining relationship and feel my ex was definitely suffering with this mental illness of immaturity. back in the loop I really am struggling. How to tell if a guy likes you, translating man-speak. The impulse to burst into tears would hit me sporadically throughout the day. ROCHESTER, Minn. Learn To Read The Signs The Right Way – Not Everything Is As It Seems Whenever the break up happens people are often curious to know if their exes are still interested in them or if they have moved on. but after six month from when he left. Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain admitted he struggled to keep his emotions in check after scoring against former side Arsenal in Liverpool's incredible EFL Cup victory. A Widow Answers The Questions You’re Too Polite To Ask he asked me to marry him. Together, we formed our identities and defined what love meant. About 312,000 customers remain without. He has all the signs that are mentioned. I was very much inlove with him so i was devastated when he broke up with me. I regret sitting at home blaming myself when he’s out “doing him”, because I know exactly what he’s doing. I did my part and let him know about my feelings to him. 10 Steps to Move On From a Relationship I can’t imagine how I could have dealt with this saga without my close friends with me. Does he love me? - 8 Tell Tale Signs "Does he love me? Or am I just imagining it?" In writing this article I'm not just giving my own personal beliefs like inferior articles available on the Internet do. As you sound to be a positive person, it would be appropriate if you respond and thank him. Can my ex-husband apply for 200k life insurance in my name as owner, himself as beneficiary, and sign for me? He is named as an insured rider (also our son is) w/me beneficiary. YOU GOT TO LIFT ME UP AND WITHOUT THIS PROGRAM REED SAYS HE DOESN’T KNOW. 13 Stages Of Realizing Just How Much Better Off You Are Without Him between my ex and me that I probably should have questioned earlier. Is he ready to commit? 9 signs he's not over his ex. My Ex Is Happy Without Me. So it’s so hard to lose this guy. I’ve been criticized about the Independent Democratic Conference. He spat on me because I was not happy with his answer and I wanted to know why. I used to like someone. "Why is my husband so mean to me?" More women are contacting me concerned about their husband's anger and how its impacting their lives. Find out what to do when your ex boyfriend is still talking to you after the end of your relationship, but doesn't want you back just yet. " I've had to ex quite a few male friends from my life because they tried to take advantage of me. Happy birthday. My question is that the County Attorney has got involved and ask me for medical records release so he can look at about me been off work for one month due to stress, but he also wants me to sign a release to give the County permission to gather medical records from any and all doctors who I have seen in the past year. Each move had to be a secret, 1 day move, since he was never willing to let me go, tho he was never happy with me there either. Owning up to your actions and their consequences gives you control over the outcome. Attracting love, or giving your heart to someone is not easy. The premiere of Season 12 of “Real Housewives Of Atlanta” is right around the corner on November 3rd and Kenya Moore has been doing a gang of interviews ahead of the new season as she prepares for her return to the show. The more you think about your ex, the less you are thinking about yourself and what is best. Happier Lyrics: Walking down 29th and park / I saw you in another's arm / Only a month we've been apart / You look happier / Saw you walk inside a bar / He said something to make you laugh / I saw. Translation: I'm not happy/and or stressed, so I need a break from this relationship, but I don't know how to say it without upsetting you. I was in the process allowing myself some time for me. However, this is their number one fear, that we will realize how little they actually give back to us, gather our OWN self confidence, and leave them. A break up is hard to bear, but moving on is worse, especially if you’re still in love with your ex. Communication is important in a good marriage, and you and your husband need to learn to share your concerns (as well as your joys) with each other. But pay attention to the context of which he speaks about this woman. 20 Medical Benefits of Marijuana You Probably Never Knew. He continues to say how grateful he is to me and how happy he is that he has me, i am the most important thing that happened in his life and then comes the hiw good if a best friend i am. Often, these same wives will tell their husbands that leaving is a mistake that he will one day regret. another is that they want someone they love to come back, but have conflicting emotions about it thinking that they aren't good enough. When my strength was what made him fall for me he use to say. " He said the gas was supposed to be thrown away after some car. But he's 6 feet I'm 4 "11. He has 3 children from a previous relationship. But overall he’s happy that change was made, as well as the inclusion of gay Scouts. My Ex Seems Happier Without Me ★[ MY EX SEEMS HAPPIER WITHOUT ME ]★ Blocked Meridian Energy ★ My Ex Seems Happier Without Me ★★ Get your Ex Boyfriend Ex Husband or Ex Gi. Was married young (20) and after 30 years (with ups and downs of course), my hubby told me he no long had any feelings for me. I would like to share a conversation I had with God during this time as I wondered, should I divorce my husband?. Est modus in rebus There is a middle ground in things. But when his ego realizes you're not home sulking - that you're out,. When Your Ex Reaches Out To You Years Later, Here's What Real Women Say It's Like and he didn't treat me as he should and he cheated me. Back in 2016, Matt Barnes declared that the biggest mistake he’s made was appearing with ex-wife Gloria Govan on Basketball Wives. My Dad is worst however, if I get into a fight with one of my siblings he'll never listen to my point of view, he will always take the younger ones side because "Your the oldest you should know better" He always looks at me like I'm shit and I've never seen him look at any of my siblings like that, but it's okay I probably am. As stated above, I now live in a small apartment and I go home from work each night and cry. You have to be cheerful and treat him like an old friend you haven't heard from for a while. but now I'm back with my ex boyfriend and I'm very happy he still loves me. From nowhere he called me and said that he is in love with for 18long years. Unfortunately, he decided to continue his affair and move in with her. Learn 21 Reasons she isn't calling or texting, excuses she'll give, and what to do. So now I have to deal with him dating around and judging me for my every action. I want that for him. Whenever we meet new people he goes on about his life as an actor, and his travels, as if he’s got no interest in our life together. Even if I was allowed to, there isn’t much to say. My ex is an awesome father, but there was a time when he was not as reliable as I would have hoped, related to what I wrote about a little bit here. Am full of anger. He has been trying to find someone, but all he’s been doing is sleeping around, sabotaging the good relationships or looking for those that could only be short term sex partners. In my situation since this girl has came into my. Not long ago, I would have eaten all three eggs, and I would have done it while I thought, “If he got his lazy sorry ass out of bed on time, then he would have beat me to the eggs. Reasons Why the Dead Appear in Your Dreams. He smiled and said, “I do. Someone told me that my ex was going through a rough patch with his girlfriend cause he was not over me/our relationship. Thinking too much about what your ex thinks can keep you stuck in a past relationship that didn't last the first time. Today I saw his pic with the girl he was once seeing before me. He would insist he had to go to happy hours every Wed. He is now married with another child and I have just recieved a phone call from him to say he is going for joint custody as he wants access to his school and medical records I have told him he can have access but he will not comply and wants to take me to mediation and apply for extra nightsto have my child. Why would I empathize with a complainer if he shows disrespect for me by making me listen to his complaint and ask for my life energy without my consent it the first place? The last thing those people deserve is empathy. 'Is your Ex over you' Quiz. You will find inspiration here to help you express your gratitude to that special man in your life for supporting you and your dreams. He smiled and said, “I do. Like I was the only one in love. I do miss many positive attributes about him and how he made me feel. Forging a secret sisterhood, wives of widowers connect over tales about loving too soon, walking on the eggshells of grief, and living in a role intended for somebody else. Please, help me to understand my situation better. ROCHESTER, Minn. The Ex Factor Guide by Brad Browning Don't make another move until you've seen this incredible FREE video! The Ex Factor Guide contains some of the most radical and cutting-edge techniques necessary for getting back with your ex boyfriend, even if he hasn't called you, and even if it seems he's not responding to you at all. I am afraid of what will happen to me. It kills me to say this. I have been with my partne for 3 years. It's frustrating when a girl or woman we like doesn't call or text back. ” without the probability of running into. So my world was falling apart. Once it was simple. I hope you got through this , I thought no one would ever love me,…it started with hugs until he molested me, and moved to another counntry without helping me get help. he asked me to send him my. He's trying to make you believe he is a good man, and he doesn't give you time to think. Luckily I had self defense training particularly in knife fighting so I wasnt seriously to injured. He was the first to make me dinner, teach me to surf in ice-cold waters and unlock the seemingly impenetrable fortress of my body. In married life, sooner or later, there may arise a situation when you have to handle your angry wife. It's less damaging to the ego to say "she friend-zoned me" rather than "she doesn't want me. I know exactly how you feel! My husband of 17. How are you doing, husband? Is your wife considering separation, or worse, are you already separated?. We never argued and were always affectionate to one another. Put a cute happy-couple picture. Oh, I'm jealous of the wind 'Cause I wished you the best of all this world could give And I told you when you left me There's nothing to forgive But I always thought you'd come back Tell me all you found was heartbreak and misery It's hard for me to say I'm jealous of the way You're happy without me I'm jealous of the nights That I don't spend. My ex is an awesome father, but there was a time when he was not as reliable as I would have hoped, related to what I wrote about a little bit here. Or he beieved I was an alien or the devil. I get value from my relationships by getting to know you much more than just being around you. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WHAT MEN SAY AND WHAT THEY REALLY MEAN. But at times, this blessing becomes more of a pain for you when they are one sided. Just like any other long-term reationship it takes work to keep things fresh and new. Why Love Literally Hurts. i can see the baby lying on my chest while he is sleeping, in the end my ex girlfriend plans to leave us. He drove me to beating him up. He even had the nerve to say to me that he "made a promise to God" I say that God does not intend married people to live a "lie" just to keep up appearances. “Her friend felt so bad for me. He says: I am bad at dating. I worry that I'm making a mistake. I was in the process allowing myself some time for me. Together, we formed our identities and defined what love meant. Palihapitiya says he wants his kids to grow up. yes my wife knows she was happy with it still is my daughter also know they alway buy me things while there out shopping my wife will bring me home new blouses,panties she like the ideal so much she was ok with me taking hormones now I have c cup breast he love it her words she get the best of both worlds A male and female at chirstmas time she. I have definitely been having a hard time letting my ex go. I cook ,clean, work and have to sort our daughter(10) alone he does nothing with her. however my patience is almost gone bc i feel disregarded and disrespected to say the least but during a vulnerable time like this i cannot begin to comprehend how he could go there and cut that deep and speak the words i love u to me. My ex-Narc married one of the women he had waiting in the wings. The Good Reminder Text. Why would he do this? Find answers to all these questions and more. This is one of the first texts you should be sending your ex, and the message it conveys to them is that you are totally over them, though you still think about them from time to time. I know I have an issue doing this because I feel bad, but dont light yourself on fire for someone else to feel warmth. Five years ago, he would have taken me in his arms and comforted me, but he did nothing. the other one is a person telling another that he loves her but its too late he is begging for the girl to come back and saying don't. 7 Things You Should Never Say To An Ex, No Matter How Hard It Is To Bite Your Tongue If you actually have found someone better than your ex, you've already won. then they respond with a city 6 hours away. Click here to learn exactly how to make your ex want you back. We have fallen out before, but this. Botham Jean's brother forgives and hugs ex-cop as she's sentenced to prison. Family law attorneys who focus on men’s divorce and fathers’ rights, such as the lawyers of Cordell & Cordell,. He is in self-preservation mode. I had a dream me my man was at sonic in a place I don’t recall but seems like we lived in that place under a sonic carport area. Love Island's Danny Williams slams allegations he cheated on ex Jourdan Riane and says he was 100% faithful. This illusion preys on people who feel hurt, betrayed, replaced, mislead, used, abandoned or ignored by their ex following a breakup. But sometimes he doesn't answer the phone when I call, and can go for days without returning my phone call. My story is a little different, My mom past away, Five month after my husband left. – in his own words, only later to find out he was sleeping behind my back with my Taurus friend. We were divorced in 2012 after a 1 yr separation. I know many of you are thinking how this is just horrible. My ex is from over 12 years ago. I did not know what it was like to be in love, like and lust all at the same time until I met you. I expect my deepest feelings to be unimportant or even laughable. He claimed to love and trust me. If you don’t want this person to be happy without you, it’s not real love. You want to know how to get your ex back from a new girlfriend or new boyfriend, but it can actually cause them to come back to you. My ex called me out of the blue. Instead he goes about sourcing and getting other customers for me of which he now asks for a little favour of the work. In the first year she spent very little time with them. Acting like you can get along fine without him will make your ex boyfriend desire you so much, he will tell you how sorry he is and beg you to take him back. " Conscious Irritation?. My problem, he said, was that I didn't choose actions based on what I wanted; I let my emotions gain the upper hand and dictate my responses instead of the other way around. Put a cute happy-couple picture. Submitted by: M. 5 yrs did the same thing to me and my two kids. The guy who was a 7 was physicsally violent while the 10 wasn’t. "Hey I want you to be happy, and this isn't my fault if your unhappy because I told you I wanted you to be happy. Obviously, the more of these that apply to you and your own circumstances, the more likely it is that your ex does want a reconciliation and have you back in their arms once again. This is happening 2-4 times a week. Even if I was allowed to, there isn’t much to say. It can only come from self-awareness, self-love, and knowing that you have real value, independent of what others think, say, and do. My ex-wife is angry that I’m happy with my new partner A twice-divorced man wants his children and partner to be together at family occasions. For your ex maybe there is no ambiguity but for you it's simply a way to get closer and to stay in contact. Each time he pushes me to my limit then blames me for everything. If your ex girlfriend is happy with her new guy, you have to remember one thing: Regardless of how you're communicating with her (e. People that know my child’s father who is an abuser and a narcissist say he does this to control you and hurt you. a lack of really good mental health,” he said. My ex broke up with me about 6 months ago he left my daughter and I aloe! He moved on to another relationship! Lately we been talking and it seems like he isn't too happy with his decision and with himself he said maybe in the future we can try things out again! He said it takes time and effort that he still loves me and miss me and our daughter!. We were together more than 5 years, engaged, bought a house, adopted two dogs. he constantly post about how life is beautiful and good and how every thing is getting better on instagram. Instead of guessing at what might make your guy happy, take this expert-approved and science-backed advice on what he'll never tire of hearing from you. My ex has an investment in proving to the world that he or she has been thriving since the breakup. Relationship Connection: Just divorced, my ex introduces my kids to new boyfriend at me and accused me of coaching our son to say this to her. Her one and only friend is crazier than my wife and this friend acted out one too many times. I was sitting in the living room balling my eyes out and my husband just walked past me without saying a word. I asked him if he still work and he said yes. He didn’t even care that his wife was next to him. via text message, on social media, on the telephone, or in person) you have to make sure that every time you’re interacting with her you’re making her feel a renewed sense of attraction and respect for you. and I hope he is as happy in. I am afraid of what will happen to me. In fact I really do love him with all my heart. When a client asks me, “Is my ex thinking about me?” or “Does he miss me during no contact?” I am happy to tell them that he/she likely does if they have done the right thing which is to give them time, silence, and space to miss them. The 26-year-old fired a dipping. So here I was, feeling pretty good, feeling like I turned a corner. He just want to make sure you mean it since it's only been 3 months. Over 1,900 Latin Phrases, Latin Quotes, Latin Mottos and Latin Maxims with English Translations. The 24 Signs Your Ex Wants You Back Here, in no particular order, is a list of 24 signs to look out for that will help you discover if your ex really does want you back. As you sound to be a positive person, it would be appropriate if you respond and thank him. My Ex and i broke up in march he cheated last year and we try working it out but he kept seeing other people behind my back is sadden me because raise his child with him for 13 years the whole time i was with him i send him to college helped him with depression and he moved out this march by may he had someone new we're still friends and he. Let's get started! Use this step-by-step guide to relationships to learn how to get your boyfriend back. He owes me 4 grand and I will NOT write him a receipt for that much. He is planning on moving in with his new girlfriend of 4 months and her 3 kids and is going to *try* to get 50/50 custody of our daughters. what will i have done if not for ultimate spell. We never argued and were always affectionate to one another. PG&E says more than half of California customers impacted by outages have now been restored about 426,000 customers, have now had their power restored. After a while I got really annoyed at this since I really tried my best to make him happy. He has his days where he gets emotional and tears up and tells me he wants to change, and that he is going too. In the first year she spent very little time with them. Add to my study list. I think the answer has to be based on the answer to a second question which you need to ask yourself: "Does my ex hate me?". In the midst of battling the reasons whether they should stay in their relationship or if it is time to walk away, they find comfort in believing that the man must love them because he refuses to bow out peacefully. People that know my child’s father who is an abuser and a narcissist say he does this to control you and hurt you. NPR interviewed nearly. he stopped calling me at work just to say hi months ago. In just a moment, I’m going to show you how to get your ex girlfriend back… so buckle up, because there’s a lot to cover. (I’m still. He told me how he felt he was depressed, that he had anxiety and that he felt like he was a nobody and that was why he wasn't happy with me going to school in order to be a somebody. I had to remember how much I truly loved my husband and the blessing he has been and is to me and our family. He told me to sell my car so he cauld buy me a new one im carless he has kept me from my family hes gone all the time im starting to drink everyday and ive gained weight hes screwing around and when i. When I walk with him, my neighbors tell me how handsome he is. Today I saw his pic with the girl he was once seeing before me. 'Is your Ex over you' Quiz. You would already know the answer. Question: "How can I know when God is telling me to do something?" Answer: Pray, especially when you’re unsure of God’s will for your life. Men & Relationships. The fact-checkers, whose work is more and more important for those who prefer facts over lies, police the line between fact and falsehood on a day-to-day basis, and do a great job. Today, my small contribution is to pass along a very good overview that reflects on one of Trump’s favorite overarching falsehoods. Namely: Trump describes an America in which everything was going down the tubes under  Obama, which is why we needed Trump to make America great again. And he claims that this project has come to fruition, with America setting records for prosperity under his leadership and guidance. “Obama bad; Trump good” is pretty much his analysis in all areas and measurement of U.S. activity, especially economically. Even if this were true, it would reflect poorly on Trump’s character, but it has the added problem of being false, a big lie made up of many small ones. Personally, I don’t assume that all economic measurements directly reflect the leadership of whoever occupies the Oval Office, nor am I smart enough to figure out what causes what in the economy. But the idea that presidents get the credit or the blame for the economy during their tenure is a political fact of life. Trump, in his adorable, immodest mendacity, not only claims credit for everything good that happens in the economy, but tells people, literally and specifically, that they have to vote for him even if they hate him, because without his guidance, their 401(k) accounts “will go down the tubes.” That would be offensive even if it were true, but it is utterly false. The stock market has been on a 10-year run of steady gains that began in 2009, the year Barack Obama was inaugurated. But why would anyone care about that? It’s only an unarguable, stubborn fact. Still, speaking of facts, there are so many measurements and indicators of how the economy is doing, that those not committed to an honest investigation can find evidence for whatever they want to believe. Trump and his most committed followers want to believe that everything was terrible under Barack Obama and great under Trump. That’s baloney. Anyone who believes that believes something false. And a series of charts and graphs published Monday in the Washington Post and explained by Economics Correspondent Heather Long provides the data that tells the tale. The details are complicated. Click through to the link above and you’ll learn much. But the overview is pretty simply this: The U.S. economy had a major meltdown in the last year of the George W. Bush presidency. Again, I’m not smart enough to know how much of this was Bush’s “fault.” But he had been in office for six years when the trouble started. So, if it’s ever reasonable to hold a president accountable for the performance of the economy, the timeline is bad for Bush. GDP growth went negative. Job growth fell sharply and then went negative. Median household income shrank. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped by more than 5,000 points! U.S. manufacturing output plunged, as did average home values, as did average hourly wages, as did measures of consumer confidence and most other indicators of economic health. (Backup for that is contained in the Post piece I linked to above.) Barack Obama inherited that mess of falling numbers, which continued during his first year in office, 2009, as he put in place policies designed to turn it around. By 2010, Obama’s second year, pretty much all of the negative numbers had turned positive. By the time Obama was up for reelection in 2012, all of them were headed in the right direction, which is certainly among the reasons voters gave him a second term by a solid (not landslide) margin. Basically, all of those good numbers continued throughout the second Obama term. The U.S. GDP, probably the single best measure of how the economy is doing, grew by 2.9 percent in 2015, which was Obama’s seventh year in office and was the best GDP growth number since before the crash of the late Bush years. GDP growth slowed to 1.6 percent in 2016, which may have been among the indicators that supported Trump’s campaign-year argument that everything was going to hell and only he could fix it. During the first year of Trump, GDP growth grew to 2.4 percent, which is decent but not great and anyway, a reasonable person would acknowledge that — to the degree that economic performance is to the credit or blame of the president — the performance in the first year of a new president is a mixture of the old and new policies. In Trump’s second year, 2018, the GDP grew 2.9 percent, equaling Obama’s best year, and so far in 2019, the growth rate has fallen to 2.1 percent, a mediocre number and a decline for which Trump presumably accepts no responsibility and blames either Nancy Pelosi, Ilhan Omar or, if he can swing it, Barack Obama. I suppose it’s natural for a president to want to take credit for everything good that happens on his (or someday her) watch, but not the blame for anything bad. Trump is more blatant about this than most. If we judge by his bad but remarkably steady approval ratings (today, according to the average maintained by 538.com, it’s 41.9 approval/ 53.7 disapproval) the pretty-good economy is not winning him new supporters, nor is his constant exaggeration of his accomplishments costing him many old ones). I already offered it above, but the full Washington Post workup of these numbers, and commentary/explanation by economics correspondent Heather Long, are here. On a related matter, if you care about what used to be called fiscal conservatism, which is the belief that federal debt and deficit matter, here’s a New York Times analysis, based on Congressional Budget Office data, suggesting that the annual budget deficit (that’s the amount the government borrows every year reflecting that amount by which federal spending exceeds revenues) which fell steadily during the Obama years, from a peak of $1.4 trillion at the beginning of the Obama administration, to $585 billion in 2016 (Obama’s last year in office), will be back up to $960 billion this fiscal year, and back over $1 trillion in 2020. (Here’s the New York Times piece detailing those numbers.) Trump is currently floating various tax cuts for the rich and the poor that will presumably worsen those projections, if passed. As the Times piece reported: